How Victim Impact Statements Can Affect an Assault Case
Under the US Constitution, criminal defendants are given the right to face their accusers. Implied, though not directly stated, is the right of an alleged victim to face the perpetrator of a crime. The whole point of a criminal trial is to give both sides a chance to tell their stories and have an impartial jury make a determination of guilt or innocence.
Victim impact statements are given before sentencing and are intended to provide the court with a better understanding of the impact of the crime on the victim and their loved ones. But how much impact do these statements really have on the outcome of an assault case, and do they serve the purpose they were designed for?
If you’re facing an assault charge, it’s essential for you and your attorney to understand the potential impact a victim impact statement may have on a jury. While these statements can be emotional and powerful, they may not always provide an accurate representation of the case, bringing both judge and jury focus away from the specific infraction. Victim impact statements are often more focused on repairing the harm to the victim than on the principles of justice and fairness that should guide criminal sentencing.
Why did victim impact statements get introduced to US court cases in the first place?
Victim impact statements were codified into law in 1991, following the Payne v. Tennessee case, where Petitioner Payne was convicted of two counts of first-degree murder and one count of assault with intent to murder. During his trial, a victim impact statement was presented by the mother of the initial victim, detailing the emotional impact the murders had on her family. Since then, victim impact statements have become standard in all 50 states in criminal trials.
What is a victim impact statement?
If you are a defendant in an assault case in Copperas Cove, it is important to know that all victims of crimes have the right to submit a victim impact statement. This statement explains how the crime has impacted the victim emotionally, psychologically, physically and/or financially. It can be used to determine the amount of restitution you may owe if convicted and can also be considered by the judge when imposing a sentence.
Do victim impact statements favor the prosecution?
The short answer is that victim impact statements play an unclear role in the case. While they provide a platform for real discussion to occur, it is unclear if that discussion is material to the case. Are they meant to inform the judge and jury of facts pertinent to the charge against the defendant? Are they meant to aid in the healing process of victims by providing a platform for a cathartic confrontation of the defendant? This lack of clarity makes it difficult to assess their efficacy and identify areas that need improvement in the victim impact statement structure.
A more comprehensive understanding of the purpose and effects of victim impact statements are necessary. Clear guidelines for the purpose and usage of victim impact statements will help ensure that the voices of victims are heard and that their rights are upheld without compromising the fairness and integrity of the legal process. But for now folks accused of aggravated assault or family violence in Copperas Cove must seek experienced legal counsel to best deal with their effects.
Are victim impact statements emotionally manipulative to the judge and jury?
According to a 2016 article in The Atlantic, victim impact statements can lead to less careful decisions by juries, as they consider emotional elements of the case that distract from the specific charges against the defendant.
This tool is useful for the prosecution, when used as an emotional pull on the jury. Your defense attorney should be well experienced in mitigation strategies so they can best support your case, in spite of the emotional weight that victim impact statements can have on a judge or jury. With that knowledge, hire an attorney from the team at the Mary Beth Harrell Law Firm, who have extensive experience in mitigation strategies of the emotional pull of victim impact statements.
If you are facing charges of aggravated assault or family violence in Copperas Cove, Texas, it is crucial to have a tenacious and experienced defense team on your side to counteract the unavoidable effects of victim impact statements on your case. At the Mary Beth Harrell Law Firm, we understand the severity of these charges and the potential consequences that come with a conviction. Our team of skilled attorneys is dedicated to providing our clients with the most aggressive and effective defense possible.
With a proven track record of success in defending clients against charges of violent crime, and we will fight tirelessly to protect your rights and freedoms. Our extensive knowledge of criminal law and our unwavering commitment to justice, you can trust us to provide you with the strongest defense possible. Don’t wait. Contact the Mary Beth Harrell Law Firm to schedule your free case evaluation and begin building your defense today. We’re based in Killeen and Copperas Cove, and proudly serve all of Central Texas, including Coryell, Bell, and McLennan Counties, and Temple, Waco, and Belton.
I’ve dedicated my legal career to defending my clients. I demand all the evidence. I investigate all the facts, the so-called witnesses and even the police officers. I make it my business to know the law. Cases can be won or lost before you even set foot inside the courtroom.
Read more about Mary Beth Harrell